Should the Mariners shut down Felix and Iwakuma?

1-2 Punch

The time of the year has come for Seattle fans to once again reflect on what is about to be yet another losing season for the Mariners. While they are 62-76 and could go on a miraculous run to finish the season at or above .500 (they would have to finish with a 19-5 run…), reality is sometimes tough to bite.

What was once a promising situation after a scorching July, Seattle has slunk back into the cellars of the MLB while fans turn a disgusted face towards the currents state of the franchise.

But all this doesn’t mean that good baseball isn’t being played. In fact, the Mariners still have what is arguably one of the best 1-2 punches in baseball with Felix Hernandez and Hisashi Iwakuma. Though their offensive numbers are undoubtedly down, the stellar pitching of these two starters still have fans coming out to Safeco to catch the final games of 2013.

However, would it be best for both the longevity of Hernandez and Iwakuma to cut them off after one more start? Each are nearing the 200 innings pitched mark and will still look to be a dominating force in 2014, a year when Seattle should start to see its young talent really develop and play well.

Let’s talk about this in regards to each player.

Felix Hernandez

Right now Hernandez has pitched 194.1 innings this year and has lost his past five starts, an almost unheard of streak when you consider that the King is usually the most dominant starter in the league. Could this be a factor of him tiring out? I really don’t think so, especially when you consider he has pitched an excess of 230 innings in each of the past four years. He’s the definition of a workhorse and looks to be in a bit of a slide that coincides fairly well with the downfall of the 2013 Mariners.

Felix Hernandez, Seattle Mariners

It’s time to shut down the King in 2013(Seattle Post-Intelligencer/Dan DeLong)

It’s a bit hard to suggest shutting Felix down for 2013 after perhaps another start (we do want to see him end the season with a win), but I really believe that is the best option for Seattle.

Look, there’s no doubting the fact that he COULD pitch 220+ innings this year, but that wouldn’t be the best option for the longevity of his career. He’s already seen a ton of innings at the age of 27, and perhaps a little bit longer of an offseason for Felix would be in his — and the clubs — best interest.

Shutting him down not only gives his arm a bit more time to recover and relax, it presents an opportunity for some of the young stars in the Mariners’ organization to get a shot on the mound as the season winds down.

So yes, while many would boo and anger at the fact of not seeing Felix on the mound, I believe the Mariners need to shut him down.

Hisashi Iwakuma

Unlike Felix, I believe there is no doubting the need to shut down Hisashi Iwakuma perhaps as soon as after his next start. While he is the Greg Maddux of Japanese pitchers and takes care of himself very well, he’s reaching the 200 inning mark (currently sits at 191 innings) and will still be needed by Seattle in the coming years.

Like Felix, Iwakuma has been stellar at times — especially at the beginning of the year. Giving Seattle two Cy Young contenders, Iwakuma dazzled opponents with his arsenal of pitches but has since seen himself off his usual dominant mark.

We all know that he is a proven commodity and could pitch another 20 innings, but once again it’s not in the best interest of him or the organization. The risk of straining his arm too much far outweighs any benefits Seattle could reap this year.

The Mariners aren’t going to make the .500 mark, Felix or Hisashi aren’t contending for a Cy Young Award, and there really isn’t any reason why either should pitch an excess of 200 innings.

Let this be a time for the young guys in AAA (James Paxton, Taijuan Walker) to really get a shot at MLB opponents and develop their skills for 2014 and beyond.


Follow our Editor "Q" on Twitter, and NWSB, 'Like' us on Facebook.
About Chris Anderson

NWSB Editor. Chris hails from Eugene, Oregon; home of the Fighting Ducks. If he is not viewing, writing about, or attending sporting events, Chris is running on the trails Eugene offers or out-and-about. Aspirations to exceed expectations. Connect w/ Chris today!
Chris On Twitter
NWSB Facebook FanPage
Chris' NWSB Forum Profile
Subscribe To Chris' Articles Via RSS On NWSB
Like Something I wrote? Hate it? Hit me back today I want to hear from you!

  • Dan Osier

    It’s a good idea, unless they have a innings pitched bonus clause in their respective contracts, based on 200+ innings. Besides the crowds are dwindling now, if they don’t pitch at home more people will stay away. We know what the “kids” can do, so who wants to pay to see the same old vets try to play baseball. It gets back to MLB prices for AA baseball, except for the AAA guys on the squad. We still need real baseball people with sharp baseball skills running our team, we don’t need Danny Kaye or the current clown in the GM position, Eric does ok with what Gentleman Jack gives him. We all know the local boys in ownership still have the “Country Club” atmosphere when it comes to procuring players and running the team. The actual owner should be forced to attend, at least, 70 home games and see what style of baseball we play. If Paul Allen or someone like him owned this team, they would not sit on their duff while the team management runs amuck.

North West Sports Beat

Sponsored Links


10 Articles To Your Inbox Daily! NWSB Daily Brew! Get It Now! Newsletter
NorthWest Sports Beat