Seattle Mariners reach new low in recent history

So many possibilities…

The Seattle Mariners announced a new low in recent franchise history. The answer could be one of several possibilities, but I’ll spoil it right off the bat for you – Attendance.

Wednesday April 18th, a lowly 11,343 fans came to Safeco Field to see the Mariners take on the Cleveland Indians. That is the lowest single game attendance in Safeco Field history.

The Safeco Field attendance record for a season was set in 2002, 2 years after the field opened. In the first 2 seasons, Safeco drew in 3.14 million and 3.51 millions fans, respectively. The peak season of 2002 saw 3,540, 482 fans pour through the gates. A decade later, that number has plummeted, with the 2011 season only seeing 1.89 million fans come to the ball park.

There are several reasons it has boiled down to this point. Let me point a few out for you.

5. Party Poopers

This one is a long shot, but talking to several fans, it is a huge contributing factor this season. When the Seattle Mariners wrote a letter to the Seattle City Council expressing their concerns over the new Seattle Arena Proposal location, it made several Mariners fans angry.

Cleveland vs. Seattle Wednesday April 18th, 2012

This was the record low attendance Wednesday night against the Indians

With the team not helping their case on the field, and not realizing they are trying to block potentially 2 new franchises from coming to the city, they have a very short rope to work with.

With the team being funded by taxpayers and the city giving them concessions over authorities like the Longshoremen and Port of Seattle, they have no room to talk and the fans are reflecting their anger over the whole thing by now showing up in a virtual boycott.

4. Poor Scheduling

I realize they play 81 games at home, but scheduling the Cleveland Indians on a cold, rainy spring weeknight is not the best idea in the world. Fans are already finding incentives not to show up to games, but this isn’t helping the Mariners case one bit.

Seeing Oakland for the MLB opener in Japan, “Opening Day” in Oakland AND the Mariners home opener is not only boring with lack of variety of opponents, but two mediocre teams playing each other does not exactly have fans jumping at the chance to go to games.

3. Dark Skies

The Mariners are used to having a marquee player on their roster that draws in fans from all over. These days, Ichiro Suzuki and Felix Hernandez are the biggest draws by far. And although those 2 have reached a high level of superstardom around the Majors, they still don’t carry the weight that a Ken Griffey Jr or Alex Rodriguez did.

Fans like to show up to see their favorite players. Fans from across the league watch games looking for that star player to go off.

And like I said…while Ichiro and King Felix are those guys these days, they have not reached and may not reach the level that Junior hit.

When we were kids, we wanted to play “Griffey Grabs” and mimic Griffey’s beautiful swing. You don’t see that with kids these days. At least not with any Mariners.

2. Ownership

Many sports franchises, not just baseball franchises, have a face of the team that the fans can identify and in ways relate to. These same faces also go out and make deals to make their teams better. The Mariners lack both of those.

Yes, Howard Lincoln is the “face” and Nintendo is the main owner, but that has really not shown much at all during their tenure of ownership.

The fact that the CEO of Nintendo is basically the “owner” of the Mariners and that he hasn’t shown up for a single game upsets fans more than you could imagine. Ownership is supposed to put a product on the field that competes for division titles and pennants and championships.

When that owner is non-existant, it really shows the fans the true colors of that entity. And the fans reflect it.

Not only that, though, is the fact that ownership has refused to spend money to bring good players to Seattle. It has reached the point where players want nothing to do with Seattle because of their reputation for being such a horrible franchise over the last several years.

If you’re not paying to bring quality players in, how do you expect to win games and win over the fans? Young talent is great and all, but you do need some veterans for their leadership and polished skills to help build a good team.

Safeco Field

This is what Safeco Field looks like when you have a winning product on the field

1. Inconsistency

Along with just flat out losing lots of games, the Mariners keep things close and even pull some of those games out. But the most consistent thing about this team is its inconsistency. I could bring you examples from recent years, but I don’t need to. I can make my point based on this early season alone.

In the season opener in Japan, the Mariners managed only 1 run in the regulation 9 innings. With Felix Hernandez pitching, they stayed in the game and went into extra innings. The Mariners scored 2 in the top of the 11th to win the game 3-1. The next game, the team only managed 1 run in 9 innings again, with Jason Vargas throwing a 1 run gem. The bullpen came in and gave up 3 runs to lose the game.

In game 1 in Texas, the Mariners tacked on 5 runs in the first two innings only to lose 11-5. The next day, they couldn’t hit to save their lives, wasting another pitching gem, this one from Blake Beavan who threw a 1 run beauty.

It seems as if when the pitching is on, hitting is non existent. When the team hits, the pitchers have a hard time of holding the leads, no matter how big or small they may be.This kind of inconsistency has been prevalent in the last several seasons and are driving fans away.

There is a lot wrong with this franchise, folks. The attendance is reflecting that accurately.

We all love our Mariners and support the team as best we can, but until there is a product on the field that ownership and the fans can be proud of, don’t expect things to change. When team leadership shows they care about this Mariners franchise, the fans will do the same.

**Side Note** These complaints are about the team itself and the ownership. This has nothing to do with game day experience as the Safeco Field employees really make each game an enjoyable one despite the product put out on the field. Safeco Field still boasts one of the best ambiances around all of Major League Baseball.


Follow our Editor "Q" on Twitter, and NWSB, 'Like' us on Facebook.
About Brandon Choate

Guest reporter on "Real Rob Report." Raised on Eastside of Seattle, a super fan of every sports team in Seattle. Bleeds Blue, Green, Teal, Purple and Gold. Likes video games, food, and poor attempts at comedy. Connect with Brandon today!
Twitter: @NWSBBrandon
NWSB Facebook FanPage
Brandon's NWSB Forum Profile
Subscribe To Brandon's Articles Via RSS On NWSB
Like Something I wrote? Hate it? Hit me back today I want to hear from you!

  • Cougsscore

    They have ruined the bullpen area for families…young drunks..i know they buy beer..but its hard to take my kids down there

    • I agree with that 100%. The outfield concourses have become havens for drunks acting like idiots. They try leave that 1 section in Left Field for family only with no alcohol permitted, but it just doesn’t work with the surroundings. 

  • mike

    well Brandon, they actually did sorta try to go for it in the Bavasi era and are still recovering – Bedard, Spiezio, the 3rd baseman from Milwaukee that could never hit (‘course they all come here and can never hit).  Plus lotsa bad decisions – take a perfectly good Beltre replacement, pay big bucks (figgy) and turn him into a 2nd baseman to put wazzizname at 3rd – for what reason???  Bucks to Lopez & Betancourt (dump Guillen for God knows what reason)  Pass on drafting a Cy Young award winner in their back yard at UW and yo-yo a born starter Morrow between relief and starter after bringing him up too soon I guess to show he was “good as Lincecum”?  Mike Morse demonstrates he can hit a ton and never good enough to find a spot for him like their doing for a much less accomplished hitter like Carp.

    IMO, the decision that may have sealed the fate of Mariner org for years to come is the decison some years ago NOT to join the National League – the option was there and everyone (including the myopic fans) was “oh no we can’t do that to Edgar…” whose wheels were literally beginning to fall off at that time anyway (like any of these guys can last forever).  We shoulda joined the NL – it’s cheaper to compete!

    So the Mariners didn’t join the NL but continue to fashion the team like an NL team – pitching, defense and small ball will never produce a consistent winner in the AL.  Fences way out there, slow grass field + heavy NW air.  Well, you have to play away games in the AL – small parks, hot, light air, ya can’t beat physics so we’re not going to rise to the top of the AL with the NL Mariners.

    Adapt or perish via dwindling fan base, etc:  bring in the fences, attract the boppers and turn it back closer to the hitting pinball arcade that was the Kingdome or find a way to move to the NL.
    A Mariners move to the NL move was and is (if still possible) best in terms of bang for the buck in fielding a competitive team.

    • I know they took a shot in the Bavasi era, but as you pointed out, failed miserably. I am still mad they passed up Lincecum in the draft, especially after seeing him pitch day in and day out just down the road. And they mismanaged a LOT of prospects along the way. Morrow as you pointed out, Ryan Anderson, letting Morse go was dumb, getting rid of Adam Jones for Bedard was dumb.

      And the NL stance is actually a good point. I’m not sure how I feel about it, but it definitely interests me to think that move over.

      I’m all for tweaking Safeco. I’m a big fan of the idea of moving in the fences some. The Mariners can produce offense in that stadium, as we saw the Mariners in Safeco’s early years set scoring/home run records. But they just can’t field a team like the ones of old.

  • To me this is just a result of seeing the sports stadium that replaced the wonderful Kingdome in all its poorness as a venue.   Safeco field is ill situated and ill designed.   Just looking at it, it doesn’t say “Seattle” to me, the way the Kingdome did, it says Brooklyn or maybe Cleveland.

    Safeco field was situated in a creepy part of south Seattle that was supposed to transform from a zone of derelict warehouses and wandering homeless bums into a sort of Urbist Paradise.  It never did.    Parking simply become more expensive and by forcing people to travel into one of the worst traffic areas you can be assured of being stuck in your car in and out.   Or, you can try one of the many buses (well, not, they outlawed the special buses that could take you directly in and out).

    Seattle and Washington State made many costly mistakes in the 2000s…and only now are we seeing just how blinded by charlatans we were!

    • I personally love Safeco, but I would agree with making some tweaks. I don’t see any ballparks as representative to their city, to be honest. I know that traits like the Green Monster and legends in NY give that impression, but those happened with time and legendary tales. With the exception of the south florida teams, it doesn’t really show.

      I do agree with the terrible parking situation, but I do believe that Edgar Martinez Way flyover and the new parking garage were good additions to help alleviate some of that. I would like to see more public transportation options as well, like them NOT skirting the buses like they did.

      As for location, I have no qualms. It’s across the street from where Kingdome stood and there were no complaints there. Directly off the freeway, downtown, and as close to the waterfront as you could really get.

      I don’t think it was a mistake at all, but they could’ve planned some of it a little better. While a choice few are turned off by those things, it is the product on the field that is killing it all. You can tell by attendance numbers alone compared to records for those years.

      People are more than willing to flock to Safeco despite the terrible traffic…when the team’s winning.

North West Sports Beat

Sponsored Links


Cappers Picks

10 Articles To Your Inbox Daily! NWSB Daily Brew! Get It Now! Newsletter
NorthWest Sports Beat