An issue the Mariners aren’t used to having…roster depth

Who’s on third?

The season is still young for this 2012 Seattle Mariners team, but they are already facing some big decisions. Usually it is regarding poor play or injuries decimating the team in one way or another. This time, the problem is much, much different. And it’s one the team is not used to having – depth. That’s a good thing…right?

The Mariners were the best hitting team in Spring Training this season. Although that’s not a big feat or going to count for anything outside of Seattle, it does pose an issue for Eric Wedge.

With so many players hitting so well, who do you keep and who do you send down to AAA Tacoma?

The Mariners started the season out sending Carlos Peguero, Casper Wells, Alex Liddi and Vinnie Catricala to Tacoma. Those were all arguably tough decisions. The factors leading up to those decisions, though, are complex and prove that this team has a good problem on their hands.

Infield Decisions

The players who primarily play third base in Seattle and Tacoma were all red hot during the Spring. Chone Figgins could finally be the guy the Mariners signed years ago, while youngsters Kyle Seager, Vinnie Catricala and Alex Liddi are trying to break through and become every day guys.

While some of these players can platoon at other positions, it is ideal to keep them where they are most comfortable.

Kyle Seager, Seattle Mariners

Will Kyle Seager stay hot enough to keep his spot?

Moving the guys they did to Tacoma made sense, although many were pulling for Catricala to make the squad after an exceptional Spring. Kyle Seager is a guy the Mariners have been grooming the longest and it looks to have finally paid off.

He’s off to a hot start in the regular season and surely does not want to give up his third base to anyone.

The every day third baseman from most of last season, Chone Figgins, started out hot as well. What do you do with him and Seager both on the big league roster and both swinging hot bats? You put him anywhere you can.

It’s hard and sad to say this, but the injuries to Franklin Gutierrez and Mike Carp are the best things that happened to both Figgins and Seager already this season. If neither of those guys gets injured, Seager would almost surely be sent down with Figgins getting the roster spot and Saunders sitting on the bench, playing situationally.

If only one guy gets hurt, it plays out the same way, because Michael Saunders, Carlos Peguero or Casper Wells were the next best options to fill in the blank. That still would’ve had Figgins playing third, but with a possibility that Seager could be sitting on the bench and playing situationally himself.

It all boiled down to Figgins over anyone, whether we would’ve liked it or not. This is not only due to his good Spring, but his big contract. You can’t sit a $9 million a year player on the bench.

Outfield Question Marks

They didn’t have to worry about that to start this season and Figgins is guaranteed playing time with the current injury situation.

This is all good and well, but it begs the question – what happens when Carp and Gutierrez come back?

There are so many situations that could play out, it’s almost nauseating to think about them all.

If Michael Saunders is still playing well, he will stay with the team, but platoon in the outfield. The Mariners need a backup outfielder on the roster in case of injury, illness, or any situation that may sit one of the starters a game here and there.

If Saunders isn’t playing well, it raises the fourth outfielder question. Since Figgins has been playing LF this season in his absence, does he become the fourth outfielder when needed?

Or do they call up Casper Wells to platoon in LF or CF?

Franklin Gutierrez, Seattle Mariners

When Gutierrez comes back, who goes to Tacoma?

If Seager is still swinging a hot bat when the guys come back, you can’t sit him down. Do you DH him and either sit Jesus Montero or make him your every day catcher at that point? Or do you player Seager at third every day and plug Figgins in the daily hole in the lineup?

If Seager cools off, do you send him down and bring up Liddi or Catricala? Or do you just bench him and use him as filler for injuries and days off?

Here’s how I think this plays out

Mike Carp will come back first from his injury. He will probably start off as DH to get him re-acclimated to the big leagues before taking his spot in LF. That will move Saunders to CF until Franklin Gutierrez comes back.

That pushes Figgins back to 3B when Carp is back in LF and Kyle Seager left in the cold, probably being sent down to Tacoma.

If Saunders has cooled off, though, he will be sent down when Carp returns. If Saunders is sent down, they will most likely call up Casper Wells unless Carlos Peguero is back and productive from the injury he suffered two days ago. Wells will start in CF until Guti is back and then platoon in the outfield.

That would leave Seager on the roster, but his role would be as a back up.

The Mariners would then have two third basemen in Figgins and Seager, with Figgins being able to fill in outfield positions as well as middle infield positions if the recent Brendan Ryan incident blows up and leads to his removal from the team.

The Ryan situation is a whole other story, I will not add that to these complications.

The combinations the Mariners could go with are mind boggling. I do not envy them one bit. They will have a lot of hard decisions to face in the near future, but one thing is certain.

If the guys stay hot, it’s a win/win for the franchise and for the fans either way you look at it.


Follow our Editor "Q" on Twitter, and NWSB, 'Like' us on Facebook.
About Brandon Choate

Guest reporter on "Real Rob Report." Raised on Eastside of Seattle, a super fan of every sports team in Seattle. Bleeds Blue, Green, Teal, Purple and Gold. Likes video games, food, and poor attempts at comedy. Connect with Brandon today!
Twitter: @NWSBBrandon
NWSB Facebook FanPage
Brandon's NWSB Forum Profile
Subscribe To Brandon's Articles Via RSS On NWSB
Like Something I wrote? Hate it? Hit me back today I want to hear from you!

  • Insider Steve

    I’m thinking even when Gutierrez does come back, it makes sence to platoon him with Saunders as a way to continue giving AB’s to Saunders.We don’t know what Guti will play like at this point. That would mean Wells gets sent to Tacoma which is fine because he should be playing everyday,

    As far as the Infield goes, I like Figgins starting at 3B full time while spelling Carp in LF. Here is where I think it gets intriguing, Kyle Seager should be getting everyday SS AB’s. His bat is too valuable and let’s not forget he has played all the middle infield positions before. With Ryan essentially in the last year of his deal, It make sense to give Seager as many AB’s as possible. He could move to 3B when Figgins is in LF. With Kawasaki doing his thing, maybe Ryan gets squeezed out? Who knows, but Seager has to stay in the lineup

  • I agree. A lot of it hinges on how the guys are performing when Guti gets back. I know he won’t be a sure thing, there will definitely be a buffer of time before you make a move, but you have to admit…with Saunders past few years with the M’s….it’s almost time for him like clockwork to sputter out. I hope he doesn’t…..but history isn’t on his side.

  • Tlbruce5

    Carp can also play first. Smoak is not tearing it up.

North West Sports Beat

Sponsored Links


10 Articles To Your Inbox Daily! NWSB Daily Brew! Get It Now! Newsletter
NorthWest Sports Beat