Predicting the Seattle Mariners 2012 starting line up

Tough decisions for Wedge

The Seattle Mariners have made quite a few acquisitions this offseason to compliment their already young roster. Most notably is the trade to get Jesus Montero from the Yankees. That move alone gave Mariners fans a shot of excitement and a reason to show up to Safeco Field this year.

The conundrum for Eric Wedge will be how young does he want this lineup to be and where does he place his 4 players who could be considered power hitters?

There are so many combinations that could work this year for the Mariners that it boggles the mind.

That’s where I come in.

Here are my predictions for the Mariners 2012 starting lineup. Complete with secondary options for each postion on the field and batting order.

Dustin Ackley, Seattle Mariners

If Ackley led off for the Mariners, his numbers would jump

1. Dustin Ackley – 2B

Why: With Dustin Ackley batting first, it would give him plenty more opportunities to get hits. The guy is a pure hitter, he just needs more chances to prove it. This would allow him the extra at-bats that the leadoff guy gets each year.

2. Ichiro Suzuki – RF

Why: With Ichiro‘s numbers declining, manager Eric Wedge has basically come out and said that Ichiro would most likely not be leading off this season.

Number 2 seems logical because he is still at the top of the order, will still get extra at-bats and with his production and consistency of getting on base, he will easily advance Ackley to start off scoring runs in innings.

3. Jesus Montero – DH

Why: Why not? Jesus Montero is a young, stud catcher who can beat the hell out of the ball. Putting him third in the order will force pitchers to pitch to him instead of around him. He is tabbed at DH to save his knees although he will platoon at catcher during the season.

Second option: Mike Carp. Carp is a guy who can play a lot of positions, but is not really stellar at any of them. He can hit the ball, though, and he will make a difference as long as he is hitting for the Mariners.

4. Justin Smoak – 1B

Why: Putting Justin Smoak as clean up hitter seems odd to some fans. His potential shows he could be the next great first baseman which means high fielding percentage to go along with some pretty nice power numbers.

He can be the catalyst to drive Ackley or Ichiro in if they are on base.

Justin Smoak, Seattle Mariners

Smoak is looking to make a name for himself this year for the M's

5. Mike Carp – LF

Why: As I stated before, Mike Carp can hit. He doesn’t really specialize in a position, but left field is most suitable as the other positions he has been know to play are locked up.

Second option: Casper Wells. Wells is a right fielder, but there’s no way the Mariners are going to move Ichiro much to the chagrin of the fanbase. Wells is a young stud like the rest of the team, who in time, could really turn out to be a solid hitter when given an opportunity.

6. Franklin Gutierrez – CF

Why: I consider Franklin Gutierrez to be a semi-power hitter. I know that sounds funny, but last season he dealt with illness and injury the whole season. He lost a lot of weight and was just out of form.

This season, he is coming in heavier and from what I have heard, as healthy as he has ever felt. He was a solid hitter to go along with his Gold Glove ability in center.

Second option: Trayvon Robinson. Robinson got called up last year and started off hot, but sputtered out and was sent back to Tacoma. He has the speed to run down fly balls in center, the glove skills to make some highlight reels and can hit well.

He just needs to refine himself a little and we’ll see him in Seattle again really soon.

7. Chone Figgins – 3B

Why: It hurt me to even write Chone Figgins name down on this list, but the fact is that the Mariners are paying him A LOT of money and will not waste that investment. They couldn’t deal him in the offseason and are going to be stuck with him until he proves himself.

They talked about him maybe playing other positions, but I don’t see it.

Second option: Kyle Seager. If Seager proves he put it in the work in the offseason, he should earn a spot. Seager is young like the rest and hit well coming up through the minors. He played a little in Seattle but not enough to get a full report on him.

Third option: Carlos Guillen. I know a third option is crazy, but I’m just throwing it out there. If Guillen proves he still has some in him, I can see Wedge giving the guy a shot and platooning at third. When he was dominant, (when the Mariners traded him in the beginning) he could hit for power and was an above-average fielder.

Mike Carp, Seattle Mariners

Carp is a great hitter, he just needs the right opportunity

8. Brendan Ryan – SS

Why: Honestly, because we do not have a quality short stop to replace him. Brendan Ryan is a fan favorite, but there is no looking past his below average numbers. He can be streaky, but was not all that consistent last season.

Second option: Nick Franklin. He hasn’t cracked the majors yet, but if he has a good showing in spring training or a good start in Tacoma, he WILL be in Seattle. He is a stud who has been tearing up the minor league system. He will be our short stop of the future whenever he is ready to go.

9. Miguel Olivo – C

Why: People knock Olivo, but he was insanely clutch for the Mariners last year.

Yes he was streaky, but it was in a good way. It seemed the few times they needed him to come through to actually win a game or seven, he was the one who took it upon himself to make the big plays.

Yes, his days are numbered especially with him slightly injured. But with a platoon, he could come in handy.

Second option: John Jaso. The Mariners acquired Jaso this offseason to add some depth at catcher.

He is not stellar, but he is a rock. He will compliment any group of catcher we have with his experience and leadership.

Third Option: Jesus Montero. As mentioned above, Montero is listed as a catcher and would love the opportunity to play catcher. I’ve got no problem with it at all as long as he doesn’t bang himself up behind the plate and affect his hitting.

(If Montero is in at catcher, Carp moves to DH and Wells to LF in the lineup)

Click Here to read my 2012  Seattle Mariners Pitching Rotation  Predictions


Follow our Editor "Q" on Twitter, and NWSB, 'Like' us on Facebook.
About Brandon Choate

Guest reporter on "Real Rob Report." Raised on Eastside of Seattle, a super fan of every sports team in Seattle. Bleeds Blue, Green, Teal, Purple and Gold. Likes video games, food, and poor attempts at comedy. Connect with Brandon today!
Twitter: @NWSBBrandon
NWSB Facebook FanPage
Brandon's NWSB Forum Profile
Subscribe To Brandon's Articles Via RSS On NWSB
Like Something I wrote? Hate it? Hit me back today I want to hear from you!

  • WWManz

    Not a whole lot of thought put into that line-up. Try this one.
    1. Ich
    2. Ackley
    3. Carp he has earned it.
    4. Smoak
    5. Seager
    6. Montero
    7. Wells
    8. Olivo
    9. Ryan

  • I thank you for your input, but how could you say there is no thought put into it? I gave perfectly sound reasoning for my choices.

    If you have listened to Eric Wedge at all this offseason, especially in the last month, you know that Ichiro is not going to lead off this season.

    Where is Guti on your list? Wells can only play left and right and I’m assuming that’s where Carp and Ichiro are, which are the ONLY spots they can play.

    How has Carp earned the third spot? He wasn’t spectacular but showed flashes of brilliance like a lot of our lineup.

    Why would you have Montero so low in the order when he is going to be our premier power hitter? If he’s at DH, he would be hitting 3rd or 4th. DH’s and power hitters don’t hit 6th in the lineup.

    I can, however, see the flip flop of my 8 and 9 hitters, but it’s unlikely since the catcher typically hits 9th.

    And as much as I would like to see Seager in there, read my note about Figgins. I’m not kidding when I say he is going to be in the lineup. He’s too expensive to bench. 

  • Cyberscribe

    The only problem with Ichiro batting second (or third) with Ackley on base is that all those infield singles become force outs at second, and with him losing a step could be double plays. He’d have to get the ball out of the infield consistently.

  • Jeremy

     This line-up I would have to say is almost 100% accurate. Ichiro is going to be out of the lead off spot. His productivity is way down from previous years. A ton of those “infield” hits Cyber was talking about have declined a ton. 64 infield hits in 2010 down to 42 in 2011. One year older i just see that number going down more. With Ackley leading off and the control of Ichiro’s bat should move Ackely into scoring position more frequently for our New Bat in Montero. That kid can flat out hit. Cant wait to watch him. And to WWManz to say that the writer didn’t put any thought into his line-up is ridiculous. He has more thought put into his writing then most people online. And to say Carp earned the 3 hole, lets think about that one. .279 avg, 12 HR, 46 RBI in 290 At bats. Those are not 3rd hole numbers, With Smoak focused way more this year than last year he is going to have a much better year this year. If you have listened to coach Wedge this off season he said Smoak has lost about 10 lbs so far and working very hard to have a rebound year, The other guy he has been extremely impressed with is Guti. He says Guti has added about 10lbs of muscle weight and is working really hard this off season to prove he does belong here. The only thing i would do different in this line up is as follows.

    1. Ackley – 2B
    2. Ichiro – RF
    3. Montero – DH
    4. Smoak – 1B
    5. Carp – LF
    6. Guti – CF
    7. Olivo – C
    8. Ryan – SS
    9. Figgins – 3B.

    Olivo would hit 7 for me because he has a better chance to produce RBI’s than Figgins does. As much as this pains me to say it Brandon is right Figgins will play. He is making to much money not to. I would much rather see Lidi, Seager, or even Guillen at 3B but its just not gonna happen. I do believe Figgins will not play as bad as last year though. Figgins at 9 makes more speed at the bottom of the lineup when the line up turns over to the top.

North West Sports Beat

Sponsored Links


10 Articles To Your Inbox Daily! NWSB Daily Brew! Get It Now! Newsletter
NorthWest Sports Beat