Blackhawks Keith gets five game suspension | Canucks Sedin will miss more

5 Games? Cmon!

Scroll down for the NHL explanation video from Mr. Shanahan.

So Duncan Keith gets five games, and Vancouver Canucks nation can debate over whether the punishment is fair, but no amount of games handed out is lessening Daniel Sedin‘s recovery time.

The suspense for the suspension will be nothing compared to the suspense for the announcement of Daniel’s injury and whether we’re talking days, weeks, or even months.

And there lies the rub.

For all the talk of suspension and retribution, it’s not bringing Daniel Sedin back.

Instead, he’s the latest star player to fall victim to an institutionalized form of headhunting sometimes called the “hockey play” (which is conventionally impossible to define) and sometimes backed up by the “hockey code”, which again is impossible to pin down long enough to define.

The league failed to stop Matt Cooke from blindsiding Marc Savard, and allowed an environment to foster where Dave Steckel Lindros’d the best player in the game.

And still they’ve learnt nothing or applied nothing because now the reigning Art Ross winner is seeing double when he looks in the mirror or family photos.

While the NFL came down hard on the Saints this week for their bounty program, sending a clear message to every other team to not even think about pulling a stunt like that again, the NHL keeps the same standard practices even when they clearly aren’t deterring anything.

Keith suspended 5 games

Blackhawks defenseman Duncan Keith elbows Vancouver Canucks Daniel Sedin. - (Rob Grabowski-US PRESSWIRE)

Suspensions and enforcers and the removal of the instigator rule are all well and good, but shouldn’t we be aiming to prevent these types of plays instead of punishing them after the fact?

Surely, the NHL would much prefer a scenario where Keith and Sedin are still playing for their respective teams instead of missing crucial games down the stretch.

Of course, these games aren’t entirely crucial for the Hawks who have a comfortable lead on seventh place and will be perfectly content to hang in sixth and face the winner of the Pacific Divison instead of playing well enough to earn a first-round date with either Nashville or Detroit.

Nothing lost, nothing learnt.

The Canucks meanwhile are staring into the abyss. No Daniel means line-juggling that trickles throughout the entire forward corps.

Think of how devasting losing Dan Hamhuis was in the finals and the effect it had on the entire blueline.

Until we learn more about Daniel’s concussion, the future is scary and vague.

The Canucks have been in the position before, when Daniel broke his foot a couple years back, but that was during the first-half of the regular seasons when the stakes weren’t as high and the competition was more of a mixed bag.

To borrow a classic Norm MacDonald line, asking Henrik to go into the playoffs without his brother is like asking Carrot Top to make a movie and then taking away all his props.

Just take everything you’ve relied on your entire career and throw it away, you can’t use it anymore.

Ok, we raised the stakes too. Go.

What fun this league can be.

Some quotes from Mr. Shanahan.

“Violation rule 45 Elbowing: Regardless of assertion that intent was to impede progress as opposed to retaliation for earlier hit”

‘Hit was dangerous, reckless and caused injury. Taken into account supplemental discipline record. 1 fine in 7 seasons”

Watch: Shanahan explains Duncan Keith ruling



Follow our Editor "Q" on Twitter, and NWSB, 'Like' us on Facebook.
About Richard Hodges

A proud Vancouverite with a lifelong passion for the home teams that some would classify as pointless and disturbing. Now realizes that The Linden Tree is not the play you think it would be.
Richard On Twitter
NWSB Facebook FanPage
Richard's NWSB Forum Profile
Subscribe To Richard's Articles Via RSS On NWSB
Like Something I wrote? Hate it? Hit me back today I want to hear from you!

  • ‘institutionalized form of headhunting sometimes called the “hockey play” ‘
    Oh, like the head-shot sedin delivered to Keith just moments earlier?  We’ve had concussion problems on the Hawks all season, it’s no surprise Keith got pissed at the sister for targeting his head and not being penalized for it.  Karma’s a bitch.

    • that’s just like, your opinion, man.


    • I_love_soccer_38

      Put your ego and stupidity aside for a second and look logically at the hits. Keith’s the puck was nowhere near Daniel behind kieth on the glass and he made no attempt to play anything but Daniels head. Daniels hit was a full body check, PPOC was not the head, the puck was there and Keith was expecting to be hit. A glancing
      blow to the head when a player is finishing a check is nothing like the clear intent to target a players head and intend to injure him. The most of Daniel will get is a fine. Don’t come complain if we send a AHLer after Keith and knock him out for a season or his career and our AHLer only gets 5 games because according to you “paybacks a bitch”

  • McHawks

    Funny how the Hawks are 1 of the least penalized teams in the league, and can play real hockey against real Hockey teams, Have you ever seen HawksVs Redwings, I might not have much love for the Wings, but the games are awesome and very few if any cheap shots. Yet Vancouver vs anyone else is always about the cheap shots. how about the knee from Burrows to Kieth’s groin, while he was being held down, how typical of them. Nobody whines like Vancouver, when they get a little of what they give.

  • are_oh_are

    Be a real man shannahan and make a statement! Dinky 5 game suspensions are obviously not working! Try maybe 20+ games and any repeat incidents should be a complete dimissal from the game…period! Stop being a pussy!

North West Sports Beat

Sponsored Links


10 Articles To Your Inbox Daily! NWSB Daily Brew! Get It Now! Newsletter
NorthWest Sports Beat